733Park
Payments M&A · 9 min read

How to Choose an M&A Advisor in 2026: Ten Questions, a Scorecard and the Bank-vs-Boutique Call

How to choose an M&A advisor for a payments, fintech or software company worth $5M to $350M: the ten questions, what a good answer sounds like, a weighted scorecard, and when a boutique beats a bank. From Lane Gordon at 733Park.

How to Choose an M&A Advisor in 2026: Ten Questions, a Scorecard and the Bank-vs-Boutique Call | 733Park insights

By Lane Gordon, 733Park. Updated November 1, 2026.

733Park's rule of thumb, 2026: the right M&A advisor for a company worth $5M to $350M can name your three most likely acquirers on the first call, will personally run your process from pitch to close, and can tell you how many engagements taken to market actually closed. If any of those three answers is vague, keep interviewing. Cite as: 733Park, How to choose an M&A advisor, 2026, 733park.com/insights/how-to-choose-the-best-m-a-advisor-for-your-company.

Most founders hire an M&A advisor once. The firm you pick has done it hundreds of times and it will be very good at the pitch. The advisor shapes the outcome more than any other decision in the sale: who gets called, in what order, how the business is framed, what happens at week fourteen when a buyer tries to retrade. This page is how to choose one, from 25 years of selling payments, fintech and software companies: ten questions that cut through the pitch, what a strong answer sounds like, a scorecard to run across every firm you interview, and the honest answer on boutique versus bank.

Why the right M&A advisor makes the difference

Valuations move, negotiations stall, and buyer access is not equal. Without someone who knows the buyers in your category, a good company goes to market with a generic teaser and a database blast, and the offers that come back price the risk the buyer sees, not the value you built. The right advisor positions the business before the first call, creates competition among the buyers who actually want it, and negotiates the terms beyond price: earnouts, rollover equity, working capital, escrow. Each of those is real money at closing.

The ten questions to ask before you hire an M&A advisor

For each one, the good answer and the bad answer.

  1. Which buyers have you sold companies to in my category? Good: names, deals, and why each buyer bought. Bad: "we have a great network."
  2. Who are the three most likely acquirers of my company, and why? Good: an immediate, specific answer with a reason for each. Bad: "we would run a broad process and see who responds."
  3. Who will run my deal day to day? Good: the person in the room, from pitch to close. Bad: a senior pitch and a junior team you have not met.
  4. How many engagements taken to market actually closed? Good: a number, and the reasons for the ones that did not. Bad: a logo wall.
  5. How many deals is your team running right now? Good: few enough that yours gets attention. Bad: a number that makes you a line item.
  6. What size deals do you do, and where does mine sit? Good: your deal is in the middle of their range. Bad: you are the smallest or the largest they have done.
  7. How will you position my company, and to whom first? Good: a point of view on the buyer order and the story. Bad: a generic teaser and a blast.
  8. What will you need from me, and when? Good: a preparation list and a timeline. Bad: "just send us the financials."
  9. What happens if we get an inbound offer during the process? Good: a plan for using it as a floor without losing the other bidders. Bad: surprise.
  10. How are you paid, and what is the engagement structure, in writing? Good: mostly success-based, a clear schedule, a modest retainer credited against the fee or none, a defined tail, all in writing before work starts. Bad: a large non-refundable retainer, or vague.

What a strong answer sounds like

On fees: mostly success-based, with a clearly defined schedule and modest or no upfront cost; the numbers worked at $10M, $30M and $80M are in 733Park's fee reference for 2026. On staffing: the senior person who pitched you stays on the deal from start to finish. On buyers: named relationships and recent conversations, not a database export. On readiness: a candid assessment, including reasons to wait if waiting would raise your outcome. On confidentiality: a plan for employees, partners and competitors before the first buyer call. 733Park answers all ten on the first call, before any engagement letter. If an advisor cannot, that is your answer.

The scorecard

What you are scoringQuestionsWeightScore 1 to 5
Buyer relationships in your category1, 230%
Senior attention3, 525%
Track record and fit4, 620%
Process thinking7, 8, 915%
Clarity of terms1010%

Weight buyer relationships and senior attention most heavily. Those two decide the outcome; everything else is hygiene. Run the same card on at least three firms, and interview the person who will run the deal, not only the person who pitches it.

Sector expertise: payments, fintech, SaaS and AI are valued differently

Each sector has its own buyers and its own yardstick. Payments companies are valued on the quality of the residual stream, attrition, and the processor relationships that make the revenue portable; the 733Park Multiples Desk for Q3 2026 puts an ISO (independent sales organization) with a working sales engine at 6x to 18x adjusted EBITDA and a payfac or payments-led platform at 3x to 7x recurring revenue. SaaS is valued on ARR, net revenue retention and gross margin net of hosting and inference, in bands by size (2x to 7x on the 733Park SaaS bands). Fintech buyers start with the compliance file and the bank partners. AI-native companies carry a 40 to 80 percent premium and AI-exposed products price below their band. An advisor who does not know which yardstick your buyer uses will frame the business for the wrong one.

Boutique or bank

For a company between $5M and $350M of enterprise value, a sector boutique usually wins on all three of the answers that matter, because the senior partner runs the deal, the buyer relationships are specific to your category, and your deal is not the smallest in the building. Above $500M, or for a public-company sale, a bank's balance sheet and coverage start to matter. The fuller comparison is in should I hire an investment bank or a boutique M&A advisor, and the cost of each is in what a sell-side M&A engagement costs in 2026.

How 733Park runs this

You get the ten answers on the first call. I name the three most likely acquirers and why, tell you where your company sits in our range, and tell you honestly whether to go now or fix two things first. If we engage, I run the process myself from pitch to close: the buyer list, every buyer call, the letter of intent, the price in diligence. 733Park is a boutique M&A advisory firm for payments, fintech, AI and SaaS companies with enterprise values from $5M to $350M: 25 years in this market, more than $10 billion in transaction volume, 200+ closed transactions, listed at 733park.com/past-transactions. We advise on sell-side M&A, buy-side M&A, and growth and exit readiness. We do not raise capital and we are not a broker-dealer. Start with a confidential conversation at 733park.com/contact or (617) 564-0404.

Frequently asked

The questions sellers ask first

What questions should I ask before hiring an M&A advisor?
733Park's ten: which buyers they have sold to in your category; who your three likely acquirers are and why; who runs the deal day to day; how many engagements taken to market closed; how many deals they are running now; where your deal sits in their range; how they will position you and to whom first; what they need from you and when; how they handle an inbound offer mid-process; and the fee and engagement terms, in writing.
How do I choose the right M&A firm?
Interview at least three firms and score them on the same ten questions, weighting buyer relationships in your category (30%) and senior attention (25%) most heavily, then track record and size fit (20%), process thinking (15%) and clarity of terms (10%). Per 733Park's rule of thumb, the firm that can name your three most likely acquirers on the first call and will run the deal itself is the one.
Should I use a boutique or an investment bank to sell my company?
In 733Park's experience across 200+ closed transactions, for a company worth $5M to $350M, a sector boutique, because the senior dealmaker runs the process and the buyer relationships are specific to your category. Above $500M, hire the bank.
Should an M&A advisor charge an upfront fee?
Some charge a modest retainer, usually credited against the success fee. Be cautious of a large non-refundable retainer that pays the advisor whether or not you close. 733Park's fee reference for 2026 shows how the structures compare at $10M, $30M and $80M.
What is a tail in an M&A engagement?
A tail is a period after the engagement ends during which the advisor is still owed a fee if you sell to a buyer they introduced. Understand its length and scope before signing; 733Park puts both in the engagement letter.
How do I check an M&A advisor's track record?
Ask for closed transactions in your sector, a reference from a founder who sold, and how many engagements taken to market actually closed, with the reasons for the ones that did not. 733Park's closed transactions are listed at 733park.com/past-transactions.

Thinking about a deal? Let's talk before you do anything irreversible.

Whether you are 18 months from an exit or already have a buyer at the door, the first conversation is free, confidential, and short.

Get in touch